Articles Comments

Naturally Educational » Literacy, Media » OMG! LOLing @ Study “Txt Msg Helps Kidz 2 Spell”

OMG! LOLing @ Study “Txt Msg Helps Kidz 2 Spell”

Can Txt Msgs Really Help Kidz 2 Spell?

A new study says…”yes”.

Honestly, I’m not terribly shocked. The level of engagement with language has gone down so far that any textual use is likely to increase fluency. What is sad to me is that text messaging is likely the only word play these tweens and teens are using on a regular basis.

Saying that text messaging improves a teen’s spelling more so than, say, watching 5 hours of sitcoms and violent movies every day, is not all that surprising. As one of the commenters on the story at ABC notes:

“I think you have to compare the benefits or harm of texting compared to the alternatives…what they would be doing instead. Actively organizing and composing of a message in text is likely to have a better effect than passively watching TV. The mental effort of encoding a message into a written textual form (writing), and decoding a text message (reading) helps the student’s ability and fluency in writing and reading, better than watching cable TV? It makes sense to me.”

I am also on board with Clare Wood, a senior lecturer in the psychology department at Coventry University in the U.K., when she states, “Sometimes, there’s an assumption that kids are more stupid than they actually are, to be quite blunt, and it’s just not the case.”

I agree that intelligence is not diminishing.

However, I believe the ability to communicate is.  Even over the short course of five years in the high school classroom, I watched the facility with both the written and the spoken word deteriorate.  Assignments I had once given to a class of freshman were a struggle for “honors level” sophomores and juniors.  Even worse, students would raise their hands to give an answer and all that came out was a string of “well…it is kinda like…y’know…when…he said…that…yeah.”

I only wish I were exaggerating.

I’ve spoken with other friends and relatives who have taught or currently teach–at Harvard and at Columbia–and some of the papers they read are truly horrific.

Most are in agreement that the students are impressively knowledgeable, technologically savvy, and driven.  The one area that undermines it all is their ability to communicate.

Yes, social media, even texting can help people refine their message and communicate more efficiently. Brevity is the soul of wit and all that.

With any tool, however, we need to make sure its medium doesn’t supplant the message. When the mere act of texting becomes more important than the content, we are losing our ability to interact through language in a meaningful way.

And the assertion that, “…students perceive a ‘firewall’ between their texting and their formal writing,” is laughable. Tell that to the professors who receive papers littered with “2 B or not 2 B”.

No, text messaging is not the end of civilization as we know it but nor are those who draw attention to the deterioration of written language merely Luddites holding fast to anachronistic rules in a land of living language.

If we lose our ability to communicate through language, what are we?

Photo credit: Zawezome

Shared at: Sunday Best at No Time for Flashcards

Follow Me on Pinterest
Be Sociable, Share!

Written by

Candace Lindemann, Yale, BA, Harvard Graduate School of Education, EdM, is an educational consultant and published writer. She enjoys new learning experiences with her children, ages 6 and 4 and 1.5.

Filed under: Literacy, Media

3 Responses to "OMG! LOLing @ Study “Txt Msg Helps Kidz 2 Spell”"

  1. My biggest issue with text messaging? I know a bunch of teenagers who text their way through class instead of paying attention. Not that that’s necessarily worse than the college student typing a paper instead of lecture notes… Text messaging really limits vocabulary – plus the text messaging culture isn’t a very polite.

  2. Rachel says:

    I know this may seem funny, and while text messaging may limit kids in spelling, it makes them crave reading and writing to each other. I love that! We have spell check for the other stuff :)

  3. Book Chook says:

    Candace, I agree. Plus, kids are missing out on so much fun and creativity when they avoid word play and creative language activities. I would love to know if children who come from homes where there is a balance of screen time and non-screen time have a different attitude and perform better!